Monetary Regime Change

The US Dollar, since the Nixon administration's era in 1971, has reigned as the global reserve currency, a status acknowledged by John Connally's famous assertion, "The dollar is our currency, but it's your problem." This position has provided the United States with unparalleled economic advantages, facilitating large deficits in both international trade and government spending. However, recent global shifts, especially in the post-pandemic landscape, raise questions about the sustainability of the dollar's dominance.

With the US deficit reaching a staggering $2 trillion in 2023 and showing little signs of reversing, concerns about foreign disinterest in holding dollars for savings have emerged. This apprehension is compounded by the de-dollarization movement, where countries like India, China, Brazil, and Saudi Arabia are actively seeking alternatives to the dollar in international trade.

The decline in foreign holdings of US Treasuries, notably by China, coupled with the US's use of the dollar as a geopolitical tool through sanctions and restrictions, underscores the changing dynamics of global currency reserves. The uncertainty surrounding the US's ability to freeze foreign reserves further highlights the potential vulnerability of the dollar's status.

Beyond geopolitical concerns, inflation and escalating government debt levels are eroding trust in the dollar's stability. Historically low inflation rates and manageable debt levels have given global savers confidence in holding assets in dollars. However, recent spikes in inflation and burgeoning debt have cast doubt on the dollar's long-term viability as a store of value.

In response to these uncertainties, central banks are increasingly turning to gold as an alternative store of value. The recent surge in gold purchases by emerging market countries like Singapore, Turkey, India, Poland, and China reflects a growing trend of diversification away from the dollar.

Moreover, as the world moves towards multipolarity, trade in currencies other than the US dollar is gaining traction. The rise of economies like India and China, with their faster growth rates and expanding trade volumes, further underscores the shifting dynamics of global trade away from dollar dominance.

While the decline of the dollar's reserve status may not occur suddenly, historical examples, such as the British pound's gradual descent, suggest a prolonged process of erosion. Nonetheless, if the dollar were to lose its preeminent position, the implications for the US would be significant, including reduced access to capital, higher borrowing costs, and lower stock market values.

The dynamics of global monetary regimes have been profoundly influenced by periods of radical commodity undervaluation throughout history. In the late 1920s, 1960s, and 1990s, these phases of low commodity prices coincided with significant shifts in the global monetary order.

One of the most notable examples occurred in 1930 when Britain departed from the classical gold standard, a system that had been in place for nearly two centuries. This decision led to the devaluation of the US dollar by 60% in 1933 and ultimately resulted in the elimination of the gold convertibility clause embedded in all Treasury debt. Similarly, in 1968, President Johnson's decision to remove the requirement for gold to back 25% of each US dollar contributed to the collapse of the Bretton Woods Gold Exchange Standard by 1971.

The 1997 Asian currency crisis marked another pivotal moment in the evolution of global monetary systems. Following the crisis, major Asian currencies ceased to be pegged to the US dollar. This shift, particularly notable in countries like China, led to the suppression of exchange rates and transformed current account deficits into substantial surpluses. However, this ultimately contributed to the great housing price bubble and the Global Financial Crisis.

Despite the historical significance of these events, few historians have thoroughly documented the relationship between commodity bear markets and monetary regime shifts. Nevertheless, it is evident that periods of low commodity prices often precede changes in the global monetary order.

The 1920s witnessed a significant commodity bear market, resulting in a 70% drop in prices from 1920 to 1930. This deflationary period allowed the Federal Reserve to experiment with what we now recognize as quantitative easing, lowering interest rates despite robust domestic economic growth. However, excessive monetary growth destabilized the financial system, culminating in the 1929 stock market crash and the Great Depression.

Similarly, throughout the 1960s, commodities, especially oil, experienced a downward trend, leading to radical undervaluation. This lack of inflation provided the US with the opportunity to pursue simultaneous monetary and fiscal expansions to fund endeavors such as the Vietnam War and President Johnson's "Great Society" program. However, these expansionary policies ultimately led to distortions in the financial system and the collapse of the Bretton Woods Gold Exchange Standard.

In the 1990s, another severe commodity bear market facilitated the implementation of the "Greenspan Put" by the Federal Reserve. This policy allowed the Fed to respond to consecutive financial crises with low-interest rates and money printing, resulting in massive financial speculation. However, this loose monetary policy also contributed to the eventual collapse of the Long-Term Capital Management hedge fund, the Asian currency crisis, Russia's default, and the dot-com bubble's collapse.

Recent research suggests that the conditions for another monetary regime change are now in place. The significant bear market in commodities over the past decade has allowed central banks to experiment with quantitative easing, resulting in a substantial increase in their balance sheets with minimal inflationary pressure. However, global tensions and the return of persistent inflation have strained the financial system, indicating an imminent monetary regime change.

Looking ahead, there is speculation about what will replace the current fiat floating-exchange rate US dollar reserve currency system. Some believe that a new monetary system will emerge, allowing countries to trade bilaterally in currencies other than the US dollar, settling current account imbalances using gold.

China's efforts to settle trade in currencies other than the dollar, particularly through gold, indicate a shift towards multipolarity in the global economy. Despite challenges such as China's closed capital account, the potential for settling renminbi imbalances in gold at the Shanghai International Gold Exchange could weaken the reserve currency status of the US dollar.

Historical patterns of commodity bear markets have played a crucial role in shaping global monetary regimes. As we navigate through another period of potential change, understanding these historical precedents is essential for anticipating and adapting to future shifts in the global financial landscape.

The exorbitant privilege enjoyed by the US as the issuer of the global reserve currency may be facing unprecedented challenges. While the dollar's decline may not be immediate, the current trends in global finance suggest a gradual transition towards a more multipolar currency regime, with profound implications for the US and the global economy as a whole.

Thank you for reading The Capital Allocator. This post is public so feel free to share it.